The Need for Heroism

If there is a rare quality and needed more than ever in politics, it is heroism, an extreme form of sacrifice of self-interest and personal gain in the service to others. An absolute sign of altruism.

This is most evident in military matters, but on any given day of the year, many people die for a cause somewhere in the world.

In general, we have chosen to reserve the word « heroism » to refer to a noble cause, and to use the word « fanaticism » to sum up the motivations of suicide bombers or those committing terrorist crimes.

Heroism should not be confused with blindness, which led the Polish cavalrymen to engage German tank divisions in 1939.

There have been innumerable heroes in French history. Four, among the most recent ones, have now been chosen to join other heroes in the Pantheon of national gems.

It is still common for others to die, known and unknown, in military operations carried out by France in Africa and elsewhere. And others demonstrate heroism through their profession (police officers, firemen, sea rescuers) or in emergency situations (when faced with a danger posing a threat to others, and risking their lives to avert it). These people come to light only if circumstances arise, without previous theory or training to face the situation.

In fact, there are only very rare cases of economic heroism, where a company owner or a senior executive would pursue the necessary reforms to save a company, knowing that he will lose his job in the process.

And still fewer are the cases of political heroism, that is to say, of deliberate choice of renunciation of career ambitions in public service so that the reform plans needed for a nation or a local community could be achieved.

One even has great difficulty in mentioning such economic and political heroes.

Among these economic heroes may be listed the company owner who merges with a competitor, knowing that he will not lead the new entity and will have nothing to gain in this transaction in terms of private assets.

Among these political heroes may be mentioned, Winston Churchill, with the claim for British rearmament in 1938 in the midst of opposition; Pierre Mendes-France steering many cases of successful decolonization, or still German Chancellor Gerhard Schroeder embarking on the reform two years before the elections. The French government that will emerge from the current turmoil in the aftermath of the municipal elections, identical or different from the present one, will have to be heroic. It should even boast about it. Turning it into a weapon of action.

After all, this government, like its predecessors extends most of its remaining popularity on the heroism and sacrifices of its soldiers. Now it is its turn to be up to the challenge of heroism.

Indeed, its aim will be a matter of saving French society from the problems besetting it. It will have to assume the immensity of the reforms to be implemented, to control unemployment and public debt. Quickly. And not only decide which reforms, but implement them also; monitoring daily its achievement. Knowing that this majority will lose almost all chances of being reelected.

This government will have to do so without fail. Without trembling. Without shrinking from different categories of criticism: Heroism is also made of determination, precision, modesty and indifference.

Politicians should not fear it, they should instead feel blessed to confront such circumstances: the mysteries of the human soul are such that, in the memory of peoples, heroes never die.

Photo: Pierre Mendès-France. Public domain via Wikipedia.org.

noor urooj

associat professor at karachi university

10y

you r very beautiful i like u very much

Like
Reply

Interesting subject, "as usual from Jacques Attali", I would say. My two cents: The virtue of heroism is misleading if it does not source in an honorable vision, whose subjectivity is its own limitation on one hand and on the other , the abnegation and altruism are the strength.

Like
Reply
Johan Bastiaansen

Freelance docent Tekla Structures

10y

The Polish cavalry charge on German tanks is a myth: www.polamjournal.com/Library/APHistory/Cavalry_Myth/cavalry_myth.html But on the topic at hand, heroism will not give France control over unemployment and public debt. Controlling unemployment requires an economic growth of around 2%. Are the politicians willing to stimulate the economy and put the control of the public debt on the back burner? It's what the economists want them to do? But they'll have to fight the establishment. Will they have the courage?

Like
Reply
Meredith Poor

Software Development Contractor

10y

"This government will have to do so without fail." Actually, not. (2) This statement puts the cart before the horse. The French people have to come to terms with their unsustainable consumption (note that the US, Greece, China, and Venezuela are in the same boat). They are not going to be told by politicians that 'the money is simply not there' - benefits that they are accustomed to will simply be whittled away. Some people will find they can't afford to live, others will lose their jobs, and those that could produce but are frustrated by the rules will depart - some sections of London have enough French citizens to what would be a good sized city in France.

Like
Reply
Meredith Poor

Software Development Contractor

10y

(3) The relationship of the US and Mexico can be seen in a similar light. In comparison to the US, Mexico has been relatively dysfunctional. Those that could move to the US did, legally or illegally, finding ways to cope until they got on their feet. In comparison to life in Mexico, most prospered. However, when the economy in the US would go bad, many returned, often to discover than Mexico had changed, and started to look more like the US. Some elements are still ugly, but the country has shifted from 'poor' to 'middle class'. Much of the reason this change occurred is because so many Mexican nationals had seen a better example, and brought those lessons home. (4) The French diaspora has plenty of good examples to work from: the UK, Canada, the US, various countries in Northern Europe, Singapore, etc. Maybe it will be a book, maybe a documentary series, maybe a charismatic politician, but someone will spark a change of mind. The message will be packaged in a way the government or unionized private sector worker can digest and accept. A lot of people know the current course is unsustainable, they just don't know what path sustainability takes.

Like
Reply

To view or add a comment, sign in

More articles by Jacques Attali

  • Ne pas choisir un camp

    Ne pas choisir un camp

    On n’est pas forcé de nier l’existence de l’autre pour affirmer la sienne. Ni comme individu, ni comme genre, ni comme…

    16 Comments
  • Les trois élites

    Les trois élites

    Une société commence à décliner quand elle privilégie les élites de l’argent, du pouvoir et de la renommée, au…

    25 Comments
  • Se préparer à tout, oser plus encore.

    Se préparer à tout, oser plus encore.

    Avec Trump au pouvoir, l'Europe doit s'attendre à tout, du pire au moins bon. Mais pour Jacques Attali, une chose est…

    13 Comments
  • The four Titanic

    The four Titanic

    The metaphor is so obvious that we hesitate to use it: watching a small tourist submarine, ironically named “Titan”…

    16 Comments
  • Les quatre Titanic

    Les quatre Titanic

    La métaphore est si évidente qu’on hésite à l’utiliser : voir un petit sous-marin touristique ironiquement nommé «…

    193 Comments
  • L’intelligence artificielle, et après ?

    L’intelligence artificielle, et après ?

    Il est tout à fait classique, et commun à toutes les époques, de penser que ce qui nous arrive est unique et que rien…

    87 Comments
  • Succession

    Succession

    Il faut s’y faire : comme on pouvait s’y attendre, après la musique, le cinéma est balayé par une toute nouvelle façon…

    19 Comments
  • Penser très grand

    Penser très grand

    Les enjeux et les menaces qui sont devant nous, chacun le sait, chacun le dit, sont planétaires et gigantesques. Et les…

    97 Comments
  • Rien n’est plus réaliste que l’utopie

    Rien n’est plus réaliste que l’utopie

    L’utopie n’est pas impossible. Elle est même la seule voie réaliste qui nous reste.

    62 Comments
  • Eloge des diasporas

    Eloge des diasporas

    Dans presque tous les pays du monde, les migrations sont l’occasion de débats très animés : dans les pays du Nord, on…

    72 Comments

Insights from the community

Others also viewed

Explore topics