Directory

(PDF) Shakespeare's Virgil: Empathy and The Tempest

Shakespeare's Virgil: Empathy and The Tempest

2014, Shakespeare and Renaissance Ethics, ed. John Hope and Patrick Gray

Empathy is a subject that could easily fi nd a home in any one of the sections of this volume. After all, early modern thinking about emotional identifi cation with another person -whether described as pity, compassion, or fellow-feeling -draws from the wellsprings of both classical and Christian ethics. To attempt to separate one from the other may be not only impossible but also undesirable, especially given that Shakespearean drama often takes its energy from the very confl ation or juxtaposition of ethical registers. Th e awakening of Hermione's statue in Th e Winter's Tale is part Ovidian metamorphosis, part Christian resurrection. Lear's reconciliation with Cordelia derives much of its power from the vertiginous blending of New Testament forgiveness and Seneca's theory of reciprocal benefi ts. 1 Nevertheless, in this chapter I aim to treat Shakespeare's ethics of empathy as a facet of his classicism, both because the classical aspects of empathy in Shakespearean drama are less well understood than the Christian and because a classically focused consideration of empathy illuminates Th e Tempest in a new way. Th e impetus for this approach comes from the rhetorical orientation of the humanist curriculum, in which learning to speak well also meant learning to inhabit and imitate the literary voices of the classical past. 2 While Shakespeare would have had access to ethical assessments of fellow-feeling in a variety of philosophical, religious, and political texts, his education in empathy in the schoolroom began through reading and imitating literary works of classical antiquity. 1 For the Ciceronian and Senecan ethical background of King Lear , see Eden. 2 Scholars have long understood the explosion of imaginative literature in England in the second half of the sixteenth century in relation to the fortunes of humanist education. Essential for this terrain is Baldwin, but see also Jones. Important historical studies of humanist education in England include Alexander and Charlton. Th e relationship between humanist education and Renaissance literature has been complicated and enlivened by a number of recent studies. See especially Barkan, Burrow, and Dolven. For the cultivation of emotional identifi cation in the humanist curriculum, see Enterline.